PDA

View Full Version : Engine Replacement Advice?



i935
06-08-2010, 11:30 PM
Anyone out on the Mid-Atlantic/ East coast had to replace an engine? Advice?

I thought I had and head gasket issue (smoke, loss of power. Compression test showed 30 psi in cylinder 4 then would drop to zero over 10 mintues and 130psi in cylinder 6. All other cylinders at 185psi or higher.) and went ahead and pulled the head. Found a blown head gasket along with a damaged piston head and scoring/groves on the inside of the cylinder wall. Not sure what caused the damage...Thoughts? Anyone ever have this issue?

Boat is a 2003 outback lsv. 5.7 liter, 350cid indmar assault 310hp, carb.

Feel like I'm getting the run around from the local dealer when I call to get a price for a new motor. Anyone have a good source for replacement motors? Can you order one direct from Indmar and or Skier's Choice?

maxpower220
06-09-2010, 10:39 AM
I had an engine in an old truck that "dropped" the oil ring in the #5 cylinder. It scored the cylinder wall badly and held little compression in that cylinder. With the blown head gasket, it sounds like a few things may have happened and it's hard to say with seeing the engine pulled apart.

Check around several places for engine prices. Check online to find the lowest price and then work on your local source to get that price. A GM crate engine will cost a different amount at different dealers in the same town, go figure.

Waynes345
06-09-2010, 11:42 AM
I've seen them on Discount Inboard Marine. Check this site and it'll give you a reference point, if nothing else. Good Luck.

http://skidim.com/products.asp?dept=1013

DOCDRS
06-09-2010, 01:18 PM
here is another place
http://michiganmotorz.com/

zegm
06-09-2010, 02:00 PM
Well I did have to have my engine replaced after putting 10 hours on it due to a tech who let a air tool get away from him. I was told the cost was around 8k for the complete engine block & heads but this was from the factory. You need to make sure that the new engine is setup like the old one or the fuel injection or carb might not work well. This is also important for all the components that bolt to the block.

james yarosz
06-10-2010, 11:52 AM
That long block from Michiganmotorz looks like a good deal for $2600.00.IMO.

keehr22
09-20-2011, 02:11 PM
Hey guys, I know this is an old thread, but I'm in the same situation and was hoping for some advice on engine replacement. Boat the boat used, turned out the previous owner had replaced the impeller, but didn't remove the grenaded pieces from the thermostat area. Long story short, big time overheat caused crack in head as well as one manifold.

Boat is a 2000 Outback LS with the 5.7 indmar assault 310hp, carb.

Marina priced parts and labor at $5000 for engine and manifold replacement. I'm mechanically inclined and want to save some money by doing the replacement myself. Does anyone have any recommendations for engine sources? Found one below that looks promising from Michigan Motorz,

http://www.michiganmotorz.com/vortec-marine-engine-1996current-p-68.html

Anyone heard good or bad about these guys, or have any other suggestions?

maxpower220
09-20-2011, 06:45 PM
Skidim has engines, but don't know what shipping will set you back. If you are freshwater only, check with Summit Racing or Jegs online or catalog. If you can pull the engine yourself, take it to a machine shop and have them rebuild the one you have. It will be a little cheaper probably.

kaneboats
09-21-2011, 09:57 AM
I agree with the thought above. If you consider the time of year we are getting to here, you have nothing but time right now. Why not pull it and have it rebuilt. It would have to be cheaper and then you know what you are getting.

Stazi
09-21-2011, 08:12 PM
Put a 383 stroked kit in it too for $700 while you're rebuilding it and get a ton more torque out of it. Then you can run a higher pitch prop for a better top end without sacrificing your hole shot.
http://www.usengine.us/marine.html

keehr22
09-29-2011, 07:04 AM
Thanks for the replies. Yeah, I have looked into going that route, and got a quote for around $1500 for a full rebuild from a local shop. The 12 month warranty offered by Michigan Motorz is what's tempting, no warranty for local rebuild..

Stroker kit sounds sweet, but I'm looking to stay as close to OEM as possible, for fuel economy and reliability.

Stazi
09-29-2011, 09:15 AM
The stroker kit will give you more torque which should actually save you some gas as it will put less load/stress on the engine with only a minimal change in dispacement. My buddy did this in his old Sea Ray and it made a huge difference to that heavy boat.

The beauty of a stroker is the fact that you swap out the crank for a larger one which has a longer fulcrum between the mains and the big end bearings - this is what increases the torque. You wouldn't even have to mess with the carb with this change.

This is similar to the 6.3L engine you see some other manufacturers offer now i many of the other tow boats on the market.

Michigan Motorz offers a 377 as a direct replacement for 5.7's:
http://www.michiganmotorz.com/377ci-stroker-base-marine-engine-20002011-replacement-p-545.html
Direct replacement for 2000 thru 2011 5.0L & 5.7L MerCruiser carbureted applications; or MerCruiser 6.2L MPI applications.
This engine is NOT a replacement for the MerCruiser 350 MAG MPI unless the ECM is recalibrated.
Rated by MerCruiser at 320-340 hp @ 5200 rpm (actual power levels may vary depending on OEM calibration and application).

keehr22
09-29-2011, 01:58 PM
That is a good point, and the extra torque would be nice for some 4 skier holeshots! But, at $4700 versus $2300, I doubt it's got 2 times the horsepower and torque of the direct 5.7 replacement.
I'm just trying to get the biggest bang for my buck, a good reliable engine from a reputable company, that way I can get the family back on the water. I think I'll just go with Michigan Motorz, unless anyone has any local references back in TN for engine shops who warranty their rebuilds?

Stazi
09-29-2011, 04:52 PM
My thought was to rebuild WITH a stroker kit which is around $700-$1000 depending on whose you buy - this would be way more economical than buying a whole new donk. The reference was just to show you that it's a viable option. I wouldn't pay a $2400 premium for a stroker form Michigan Motorz, either.

There should be a engine builder in TN that could do this for you with some sort of warranty. The pull out an rebuild should be super quick, almost as fast as buying a drop in.

viking
09-30-2011, 12:29 AM
Heck - Docdrs just rebuilt his seadoo in a few days. Buy him a round trip ticket, have all the parts ready, and in a weekend he'll have that thing purring like a kitten :)

keehr22
09-30-2011, 04:47 AM
Stazi - That's a real good point. So you don't think I'll have tuning issues using the stroker kit with my same OEM carb and intake? I'll have to call around and see what I can find for machine shops that back their work, I'll spread the search out to some nearby cities.

Viking - Nice, if only it were that easy! My wife sunk our seadoo last year, I ended up doing the rebuild myself, stupid thing never did run right after, so big kudo's to docdrs! I got great compression, but wiring was messed after becoming a bobber in the lake. Wanted to get it back on the water for her, with a big sticker on the back; "Yellow Submarine"

Stazi
09-30-2011, 08:59 AM
keehr22 - You shouldn't have to mess with the carb at all, except perhaps a slight adjustment of the idle mixture screws, but that's to be expected with any rebuild, due to part-to-part variation. The displacement increase is really not that much (+9.4%) so nothing the stock carb can't handle. It will be night and day when you go for that first pull though as the extra torque will be evident. You may, as I mentioned previously, be able to go a degree up or too in pitch on your prop (after break-in) if you so desire, to increase your top end speed (if that's important to you), without sacrificing your hole shot. That is of course only if you aren't going to put 1000's of pounds of extra ballast in it - in which case I would stick with the prop you have.

Knock on wood, but if I had to rebuild my motor, I wouldn't hesitate stroking it.

Like we say in Australia, "If you want more inches, stroke it":p

moombahighrider
10-01-2011, 03:17 AM
keehr22 -

Like we say in Australia, "If you want more inches, stroke it":p

Stazi, are you an Aussie? Do you live here in the states? I have not come across to many of us that own moomba's that are Australian.

Stazi
10-01-2011, 06:17 PM
Stazi, are you an Aussie? Do you live here in the states? I have not come across to many of us that own moomba's that are Australian.
Bloody oath, mate!
I'm a sandgroper, from Perth, but have been living in the Detroit outer suburbs for the last 12 years now.

chawk610
10-04-2011, 09:01 AM
Bloody oath, mate!
I'm a sandgroper, from Perth, but have been living in the Detroit outer suburbs for the last 12 years now.

Ahhh... Perth, land of, "hey, lets get bit in half by a white shark!" :)